This paper makes a comparative study of political life with its attendant sociological attributes in two villages in West Bengal. In one, in Singur district, the proposed Tata Motors project has led to a violent agitation and to people turning away from the Left Front. In the other, in Hooghly district, even though the tribals and lower castes are disenchanted with the LF, they continue to support it because they find the alternative even more unacceptable. The paper asserts that the phenomenon of the Indian villager eager to "desert the fields for a future outside the mud halls of their homes" is more apparent than real.